Blog

Key Takeways

• Spot quantity stays low and liquidity skinny in Bitcoin markets
• Only 2.7% of the provide has moved in the final week; 7% has moved in the final month
• This compares to 7% of the complete provide of Bitcoins which are doubtless misplaced 
• Uncertainty is excessive resulting from tightening regulation and the macro local weather
• With establishments submitting ETFs and launching exchanges, the liquidity picture might change drastically in the future

Market individuals will know that if something is true about the Bitcoin market over the final 12 months, it’s that it has been extremely illiquid. 

Market depth was skinny anyway by the time November 2022 rolled round. Then got here the FTX implosion and an Alameda-sized gap so as books. Bankman-Fried’s buying and selling agency was additionally one in every of the largest market makers round, and market depth has by no means recovered since its demise. 

The impact has worsened in the final few months because of the regulatory clampdown in the US. We noticed a number of market makers wind again operations in the US, together with Jump Crypto and Jane Street in May (mockingly, Bankman-Fried labored for the latter earlier than founding Alameda). 

We put collectively a data dive on this again in March, but in the steadiness of stablecoins on exchanges under, we will see 60% have left exchanges in simply over six months, amounting to $26 billion. 

We can even see under that a lot of the quantity earlier in the 12 months was derived from Binance through zero-fee promotions. Once this promotion ceased, the futures-to-spot quantity ratio jumped, highlighting that even that skinny stage of spot quantity was propped up considerably artificially by zero charges (chart through Kaiko).

Indeed, one in every of the (many) prices dealing with Binance is that the trade engaged in “targeted wash trading” to extend volumes. Therefore, the shallow quantity could be even shallower in actuality. 

By now, everyone knows this. I need to take a second to evaluate the provide aspect of the equation, nonetheless. From day 1, Bitcoin has possessed two qualities which make it ever-so-intriguing: a ultimate capped provide of 21 million cash and a pre-determined schedule at which these cash are launched (with the provide cap slated to be hit in the 12 months 2140). 

As of at this time, 92.4% of the Bitcoin provide has already been launched. By pulling some on-chain knowledge, I’ve plotted under the proportion of cash which have moved in the final month towards the complete provide. This offers some indication into what number of cash are shifting resulting from buying and selling exercise. 

The chart exhibits 1.4 million cash have moved in the final month, equal to 7% of the circulating provide. In fact, one month is probably going too broad a time horizon. Narrowing it to a (nonetheless conservative) one week in the subsequent chart exhibits round half 1,000,000 cash shifting, round 2.7% on the complete provide.  

These charts spotlight additional how few Bitcoins are actually shifting round as of late. In truth, if I can use yet one more chart for example the shortage at play right here, let’s have a look at this subsequent one which layers in an estimate of misplaced cash. These misplaced cash are estimated by Glassnode and are cash which have been inactive since earlier than the launch of the first Bitcoin trade in July 2010 (as cash from pre-July 2010 are spent, this estimate converges to the actual variety of misplaced cash; it’s not an ideal measure, but a superb estimate). 

The chart exhibits that 7.5% of the complete provide will be at the moment estimated as misplaced (Satoshi Nakamoto’s stash is included right here). That implies that it’s roughly the identical quantity as the quantity of cash which have moved in the final month, and triple the variety of cash which have moved in the final week. 

Therefore, solely a small portion of the provide is shifting for Bitcoin. On one hand, this sounds bullish – one oft-repeated mantra inside the house is {that a} dwindling provide will inevitably result in an uptick in value. But that is solely the case if the skinny provide is matched by an uptick in demand. 

When we have a look at order books and market depth over the final 9 months, the shallow liquidity is a priority. However, there have been a number of essential developments in the final two weeks that present hope that this will likely change. Blackrock, the world’s largest asset supervisor, filed for a spot Bitcoin ETF, solely to be swiftly adopted by fellow large Fidelity. There can also be the launch of the trade EDX, backed by trad-fi giants Fidelity, Schwab and Citadel.

Even the tightening regulatory noose round Binance could assist present a clearer picture for the way forward for the house and provides buyers confidence that one thing is lastly being completed to scrub up the opaque nature of a lot of the trade. 

In conclusion, it feels fairly doubtless that we are going to be trying again upon these uber-thin liquidity circumstances in awe in a few years’ time. Uncertainty is excessive proper now, each with regard to regulation but additionally the macro picture. There will come a day when that gained’t be the case, and issues could also be very totally different consequently. But as of proper now, it’s skinny on the market.